Fans of Days of Our Lives know that soap operas often bring surprises, and one of the biggest twists is when a familiar face suddenly looks… different! In the world of soap operas, characters being recast is fairly common, and Days of Our Lives has certainly had its share of recasts over the years.
Let’s take a look at ten memorable times when the show switched actors, leaving fans either excited or shocked.
1. Jennifer Horton
Jennifer Horton has been a central character on Days of Our Lives for decades, and while most viewers associate the role with Melissa Reeves, there’s actually a more complex history behind this fan-favorite character.
Jennifer was originally portrayed by actress Maren Stephenson when the character first appeared in 1976, but she was soon recast with Reeves taking over in 1985.
Melissa Reeves became so synonymous with Jennifer that when she temporarily left the show in 1995, her departure was a big shock to viewers. During Reeves’ break, actress Stephanie Cameron stepped in to play the role, creating a temporary—but significant—recasting that fans still talk about today.
Then in recent years, when Reeves chose to step away from the role once again, Days producers called on Cady McClain to fill her shoes. McClain’s take on Jennifer was well-received by most fans, but many were thrilled when Reeves returned once more, solidifying her place as Jennifer in fans’ hearts.
This character’s journey through multiple recasts shows how soap operas can successfully transition characters without losing the essence of what makes them special.
Behind-the-scenes: Melissa Reeves originally left due to personal reasons, which opened up the opportunity for Stephanie Cameron to step in. In 2020, the role was recast again with Cady McClain when Reeves decided not to return amidst the COVID-19 pandemic.
2. Roman Brady
Roman Brady’s character has been at the center of Days of Our Lives drama for decades, and his recasting story is one of the most memorable in the show’s history. Roman was originally portrayed by Wayne Northrop, who helped establish the character as a tough but loving family man. However, when Northrop left the show in 1984, the producers faced the challenge of keeping such a vital character on screen.
Their solution? Recast Roman with Drake Hogestyn, but with a twist—fans later learned that Hogestyn’s character wasn’t Roman at all but a new character, John Black. Roman’s true identity was then restored when Josh Taylor took over the role in 1997.
This long-running storyline of Roman and John’s intertwined identities kept fans guessing for years and made Roman’s recasting one of the most talked-about in Days history.
Fan reactions: Roman’s multiple recasts initially left fans confused, especially with the complex identity swap with John Black. However, once the storyline was explained, it became one of the show’s most iconic plots.
3. Bo Brady
Bo Brady, one half of the legendary Bo and Hope supercouple, is another Days character with a memorable recast. Peter Reckell was the original actor to play Bo when the character first appeared in 1983, and his portrayal quickly made him a fan favorite.
Reckell’s rugged charm and undeniable chemistry with Kristian Alfonso’s Hope made them one of the most beloved couples in daytime television.
However, when Reckell left the show in 1992, fans were introduced to a new Bo played by Robert Kelker-Kelly. Kelker-Kelly’s version of Bo was noticeably different, and while many fans accepted him in the role, others longed for Reckell’s return. In 1995, those fans got their wish when Reckell returned to reclaim the role, and he continued to play Bo until his departure in 2012.
Behind-the-scenes: Peter Reckell’s decision to leave Days was to pursue other acting opportunities, which opened the door for Robert Kelker-Kelly’s temporary stint. Fans were excited when Reckell returned, bringing Bo’s original charm back to the screen.
4. Marlena Evans
Marlena Evans is perhaps one of the most beloved characters on Days of Our Lives, and for good reason. Portrayed by Deidre Hall for most of her time on the show, Marlena has been through some of the most dramatic and supernatural storylines, from demonic possession to miraculous resurrections.
However, there was a brief period in the 1980s when Hall left the show, and Marlena was recast with actress Donna Beck stepping into the role. While Beck’s portrayal was short-lived, it stands as one of the rare moments when Days had to recast such an iconic character. Fans were overjoyed when Hall returned to the role and continued Marlena’s storyline, further cementing her place as one of soap opera’s greatest heroines.
Fan reactions: The recasting of Marlena wasn’t well-received by many fans, who were attached to Deidre Hall’s portrayal. When Hall returned, it felt like a victory for longtime viewers.
5. Jack Deveraux
Jack Deveraux’s character is one of the most recast in Days history, with several actors taking on the role over the years. Matthew Ashford is undoubtedly the most well-known actor to play Jack, having portrayed him on and off since 1987.
However, during Ashford’s breaks from the show, other actors stepped in to fill the role, including Mark Valley, who played a more serious version of Jack in the mid-1990s.
Valley’s portrayal was significantly different from Ashford’s, with a more stoic and less comedic take on the character. This difference in tone caused some division among fans, but Ashford’s eventual return brought Jack’s signature charm and humor back to the forefront.
Behind-the-scenes: The multiple recasts of Jack were largely due to Ashford’s departure from the show to pursue other projects. Each recast brought a different take on the character, but Ashford’s return always seemed to bring Jack back to his original roots.
6. Belle Black
Belle Black has been played by a few actresses over the years, but Kirsten Storms is probably the actress who left the most lasting impression during her run as a teenager in the early 2000s.
When Storms left the show, Martha Madison stepped in to portray Belle as an adult, and her version of the character has become the definitive one for many fans.
Madison’s portrayal brought a more mature and grounded side to Belle, especially as the character became a mother and navigated her complex relationships. The recast allowed the character to evolve, and Madison continues to play Belle to this day.
Fan reactions: While fans loved Kirsten Storms’ portrayal of Belle, many were won over by Martha Madison’s performance, which gave Belle a more grown-up and relatable presence.
7. Philip Kiriakis
Philip Kiriakis has been recast several times throughout Days of Our Lives’ history, with Jay Kenneth Johnson and Kyle Brandt being the two most notable actors to play the role.
Each actor brought something different to Philip—Johnson’s portrayal focused more on the character’s emotional and vulnerable side, while Brandt’s version highlighted Philip’s ambition and drive.
Fans have embraced both portrayals, with each actor adding unique layers to Philip’s personality. While the character has been through various ups and downs, the multiple recasts have kept him relevant in the constantly shifting world of Salem.
8. Hope Brady
Hope Williams Brady, one of the show’s most beloved characters, was famously portrayed by Kristian Alfonso for decades. However, before Alfonso took over the role, Hope was actually played by actress Tammy Taylor during the character’s early years.
Once Alfonso took over, she made the role her own, becoming one of the most iconic faces in Days of Our Lives history.
Fan reactions: While Tammy Taylor’s portrayal was short-lived, Alfonso’s performance solidified Hope as a fan favorite, and she remains one of the show’s most cherished characters.
9. EJ DiMera
EJ DiMera is one of the newer characters on this list, but his recast was still a big deal for fans. Originally portrayed by James Scott, EJ became a central figure in Salem, particularly in his tumultuous relationship with Sami Brady. When Scott left the show, many fans wondered if the character could ever return.
In 2021, Dan Feuerriegel took over the role, bringing a fresh take on EJ while maintaining the character’s signature DiMera charm. Fans have embraced Feuerriegel’s portrayal, and his version of EJ continues to stir up drama in Salem.
Fan reactions: While some fans were hesitant about a new EJ, many have praised Feuerriegel’s performance, appreciating his ability to capture EJ’s essence while adding his own flair.
10. Will Horton
Will Horton’s character has had an interesting journey, with multiple actors stepping into the role over the years. Chandler Massey is perhaps the most well-known actor to play Will, especially for his groundbreaking storyline as one of the first openly gay characters on daytime television.
Before Massey, Will was played by a series of child actors, and after Massey’s departure, the role was temporarily taken over by Guy Wilson. Each actor brought their own unique spin to Will, but Massey’s portrayal remains the most beloved by fans.
Fan reactions: Chandler Massey’s portrayal of Will was a landmark moment in Days history, and his return to the role after Guy Wilson’s stint was widely celebrated by fans.
Conclusion
In a long-running soap like Days of Our Lives, recasts are inevitable. While some changes can feel jarring to fans, they also give characters new life and add layers to their storylines. Whether it’s a temporary switch or a permanent change, recasts keep the show fresh and exciting.
Fan Reactions: Recasts are a common part of soap operas, but they always come with mixed feelings from fans. Some enjoy the fresh takes, while others long for the original actors to return. No matter how they feel, one thing is certain: recasts keep the storylines alive, evolving, and always interesting.
Interactive Element
Now it’s your turn—who was your favorite recast on Days of Our Lives? Vote in our poll below and let us know!